Exterior Design
May 21, 2024

PVC vs Composite Decking: A Deck Material Guide

Explore PVC vs composite decking, focusing on their durability, aesthetics, costs, and environmental impact to help you choose the best material for your deck.‍

Choosing the right decking material can be a daunting task, affecting everything from the aesthetic charm of your outdoor space to its longevity and maintenance needs. The decision between PVC vs composite decking is particularly challenging, as each material offers distinct advantages and considerations. This guide aims to clarify these options to ensure your deck is both beautiful and functional.

At CommonWealth Contractors, we understand the importance of selecting the right materials for your project. Our extensive experience with PVC vs composite decking enables us to provide insights that help homeowners make informed decisions based on durability, maintenance, and overall value. Whether you're building a new deck or refurbishing an existing one, CommonWealth Contractors is here to guide you through every step.

Continue reading to dive deeper into the specifics of PVC vs composite decking. This article will explore key considerations such as environmental impact, aesthetic possibilities, and long-term costs. Let us help you navigate the complexities of decking materials to find the perfect fit for your lifestyle and budget.

What is PVC Decking?

PVC decking stands out in the decking world for its robust build and minimal maintenance requirements. Known for its excellent resistance to environmental elements, it's an ideal choice for homeowners looking for durability and ease of care.

The material's composition from polyvinyl chloride means no wood fibers are present, enhancing its moisture resistance and reducing susceptibility to rot. PVC's light weight simplifies the installation process and could potentially lower labor costs. Notably, it maintains its vibrant color over time, even under UV exposure, and is fully impervious to mold and mildew—crucial for areas that experience significant rainfall or humidity.

Advanced PVC decking uses high-performance polymers for added durability against scratches and stains. Many products feature recycled plastics, enhancing environmental sustainability without compromising quality. These decking options come in various colors and textures, allow customization to fit personal style, stay cooler underfoot in sunny climates, and often come with extended warranties to ensure long-term satisfaction and investment protection.

an infographic of the different appealing features of PVC & Composite Deck Materials
The Different Material Features that Make PVC & Composite Decks Unique & Appealing

What is Composite Decking?

Composite decking offers a popular alternative to traditional wood and PVC, crafted from a blend of wood fibers and plastic. This material is celebrated for its robustness and ability to withstand weather and wear far better than wood alone.

The eco-friendly nature of composite decking stems from its use of recycled materials, making it a more sustainable option than fully synthetic counterparts. Technological advancements allow it to closely mimic the natural look and feel of wood, offering the aesthetic appeal of traditional wood without the high maintenance.

Designed for longevity, composite decking resists fading, staining, and mold, helping it maintain its appearance over time. This durability makes it an excellent choice for homeowners seeking a beautiful, low-maintenance outdoor living area.

PVC vs. Composite Decking: Which Lasts Longer?

When choosing between PVC vs composite decking, understanding how each material stands up to environmental challenges, wear and tear, and the test of time is vital. Let’s examine their performance in these key areas to help you determine which decking might best meet your needs for durability and longevity.

  • Which Handles the Elements Better? PVC decking excels in climates with extreme temperature fluctuations, maintaining stability without significant expansion or contraction. Composite decking performs well overall but can be prone to some warping in similar conditions.
  • How Do They Stand Up to Traffic? Composite decking is known for its durability in high-traffic areas, resisting daily wear effectively. PVC, while durable, is more likely to show scratches, which may be a concern in busy or pet-friendly homes.
  • The Ultimate Test of Durability: Top-quality PVC decking can last over 50 years, outperforming composite thanks to its fully synthetic composition resistant to rot and mold. Composite decking generally promises a lifespan of around 25-30 years, robust but shorter than PVC.
  • Will Your Deck Fade? PVC retains its color and appearance longer than composite, which, despite improvements, may still exhibit some fading over extensive use. This makes PVC a better choice for those prioritizing long-term aesthetic stability.

PVC vs. Composite Decking: Which is Easier to Maintain?

Choosing decking materials with minimal upkeep is essential for maximizing your outdoor living space's enjoyment and value without the burden of constant maintenance. Less maintenance not only simplifies homeownership but also translates into significant time and cost savings over the years.

  • Regular Cleaning: Both PVC and composite decks require regular cleaning to maintain their appearance. However, composite decking may need slightly more frequent and thorough cleaning due to its wood content, which can attract dirt and mildew.
  • Forget Staining and Sealing! A major advantage of both PVC and composite decking over traditional wood is that they do not require staining or sealing. This not only saves significant time and effort but also reduces long-term maintenance costs.
  • Scratches and Damage: PVC decking may be more susceptible to visible scratches, which can be more challenging to repair compared to those on composite decks. However, both materials are designed to resist significant damage, enhancing their durability.
  • How Do They Hold Up Over Time? Over many years, composite decking might show signs of wear such as color fading and could require board replacement or color treatments to restore its original appearance. This aspect might increase the overall maintenance effort compared to PVC.
  • Ease of Maintenance: When it comes to the easiest maintenance routine, PVC decking often outshines composite. PVC's requirement for only occasional cleaning without the need for stain or seal treatments makes it a preferable option for those seeking minimal upkeep.

Design Choices for Your Dream Deck

Selecting the right decking involves creating a space that reflects your style and meets your functional needs. Both PVC and composite decking offer a range of design options, but understanding their differences can help you decide which best suits your vision for the perfect outdoor environment.

an infographic of the different aspects of deck to consider when determining the right deck material for a home
The Different Choices Involved in Deciding Which Deck Material is Right for A Home
  • Color Options: Both PVC and composite decking provide a broad spectrum of colors, from traditional wood tones to modern grays and earth tones, allowing for full customization of your deck's appearance. This variety ensures that you can match your decking to the existing style and color palette of your home.
  • Texture and Finish: If you're aiming for a deck with a natural wood look, composite decking usually offers a more realistic wood grain texture. In contrast, PVC decking tends to provide a smoother, more uniform finish, which can complement a more contemporary home design.
  • Customization: The ability to customize your deck extends beyond color and texture. Both PVC and composite materials come in various profile designs, board widths, and railing options. This flexibility allows you to tailor every aspect of your deck to meet specific aesthetic and functional requirements.
  • Will Your Deck's Color Last? Long-term color retention is crucial for maintaining the original appeal of your deck. PVC decking typically excels in maintaining its color and appearance without fading, even under prolonged sun exposure, making it a great choice for sunny locales.
  • Which is More Realistic? Both decking types are designed to mimic the look and feel of natural wood, but composite decking often edges out in authenticity, offering more detailed textures and color variations that more closely resemble real wood. This can be particularly appealing if you are looking for a deck that blends seamlessly with a natural outdoor setting.

PVC vs. Composite Decking: Installation Costs and Long-Term Value

When planning a new deck, the choice between PVC and composite materials impacts both aesthetics and economics. This section delves into the installation costs and long-term value of each, helping you make an informed decision that balances initial expenses with future savings.

  • Installation Ease: Composite decking is known for its workability, which can make the installation process quicker and potentially cheaper in terms of labor. PVC decking, while durable, is slightly more brittle and may require special tools for installation, which can add to the labor costs if not managed properly.
  • Labor Costs: Generally, the installation costs for both PVC and composite materials are similar, but the lighter weight of PVC could result in lower labor costs because it's easier and faster to handle during the installation process.
  • Material Costs: PVC decking typically has a higher initial cost compared to composite decking. However, the superior longevity and lower maintenance needs of PVC can offset these upfront costs, providing better value over the deck's lifespan.
  • Which Saves You More Long-Term? While composite decking offers great value through its affordable upfront cost and durable nature, PVC decking potentially offers greater long-term savings. The extended lifespan and minimal upkeep associated with PVC can make it a more cost-effective option over many years.

The Environmental Impact of PVC vs. Composite Decking

As homeowners increasingly prioritize sustainability, the environmental impact of building materials, especially for outdoor decking, becomes a crucial factor in decision-making. Understanding these factors will help you choose a decking material that aligns with both your aesthetic preferences and environmental values.

  • Production Processes: Composite decking often gets an eco-friendly nod for using recycled materials like wood scraps and plastics. This helps reduce its environmental footprint.
  • Recyclability: When a deck reaches the end of its life, PVC is generally easier to recycle than composite decking.
  • Environmental Footprint: PVC is made from petroleum, which means its production has a higher environmental impact than composites that use recycled materials.
  • Sustainability Features: The good news is that many manufacturers of both PVC and composite are now making their decking in more environmentally friendly ways. They're cutting down on harmful emissions and improving the recyclability of their products.
  • Eco-Friendly Options: If sustainability is a top priority for you, look for manufacturers with a strong commitment to responsible environmental practices when choosing your decking material.

Comfort and Safety Features of Decking Materials

Ensuring the safety of your deck is crucial for your enjoyment and peace of mind. PVC and composite decking materials offer unique features that enhance these essential aspects.

an infographic of the safety features associated with PVC & Composite Decks
An Overview of the Safety Features Asssociated With PVC & Composite Decks
  • Surface Temperature: Composite decking remains cooler than PVC, which is beneficial in hot climates where decks are exposed to prolonged sunlight. This keeps the deck comfortable for barefoot walking during the warmer months.
  • Slip Resistance: Both PVC and composite decking can include anti-slip textures, vital for safety in moist areas or regions with frequent rainfall, ensuring a safer environment around pools and during wet conditions.
  • Splinter and Warp Resistance: Choosing materials that do not splinter or warp, such as PVC and composite, enhances safety by providing a more stable and reliable walking surface, making them superior to traditional wood decking in this regard.
  • Fire Resistance: Considering the fire ratings of your decking material is important, particularly in wildfire-prone areas. Both PVC and composite materials can be chosen for their higher fire resistance, offering peace of mind through added safety features.
  • General Safety: The absence of harmful chemicals needed for sealing or staining with PVC and composite decking reduces exposure to potential toxins, making these materials safer choices for households, especially those with children and pets.

Choosing the Right Material for Your Deck

Selecting the ideal material for your deck involves a balance between functionality, budget, style, environmental impact, and maintenance requirements. Understanding these aspects will ensure your deck not only fits your lifestyle but also your long-term satisfaction and budget.

an infographic of tips on how to choose the right material for a Deck
Considerable Tips on How to Choose the Right Material for A Deck
  • Lifestyle Compatibility: Consider the deck's intended use and expected foot traffic. High-traffic areas or frequent entertainment might demand a more durable material like PVC, which can withstand heavy use without significant wear.
  • Budget Considerations: Initial costs versus long-term savings play a critical role in material selection. While PVC typically involves a higher upfront cost, its longevity may offer greater savings over time. Conversely, composite decking might be more cost-effective initially but could incur higher maintenance costs.
  • Aesthetic Preferences: Your home’s style should guide the decking material choice. Composite decking offers a more natural wood look, ideal for traditional aesthetics, whereas PVC provides a wide range of modern finishes suitable for contemporary designs.
  • Environmental Concerns: For those prioritizing sustainability, composite decking made from recycled materials is preferable, offering a reduced environmental footprint compared to PVC.
  • Maintenance Willingness: If low maintenance is a priority, PVC decking is advantageous as it generally requires less upkeep than composite, saving time and effort in long-term care.

Why Choose Commonwealth Contractors for Your Decking Needs

Since its inception, Commonwealth Contractors has built a reputation on the pillars of quality, sustainability, and client-focused construction. Our long-standing history in the community reflects our commitment to excellence and innovation in every project we undertake. As we continue to evolve, our core values remain centered around providing top-tier decking solutions tailored to each homeowner's unique preferences and needs.

an infographic of services provided by Commonwealth Contractors
Exterior Services Provided By Commonwealth Contractors, Top Tier Contractors
  • Sustainable Materials: We prioritize eco-friendly practices by utilizing recycled materials for both PVC and composite decking. This approach not only enhances the environmental friendliness of our projects but also ensures that your new deck is built with materials that are both durable and responsibly sourced.
  • Custom Designs: Our designs are fully customizable, ensuring that every deck we build aligns perfectly with the homeowner's vision and style. We work closely with you to understand your aesthetic and functional requirements, transforming your ideas into a beautiful and practical outdoor living space.
  • Expertise in Decking: With years of specialized experience, we bring a deep understanding of both PVC and composite decking to every project. Our skilled team ensures that no detail is overlooked, from the initial design to the final installation, providing a flawless finish that exceeds expectations.
  • Quality Craftsmanship: Our commitment to craftsmanship means we use only the best techniques and materials to ensure durability and beauty. Each deck is constructed with precision and care, guaranteeing that it not only looks great but also stands the test of time.
  • Environmental Responsibility: We're dedicated to reducing our environmental footprint, from the production process to the final installation. Our projects are designed to be as sustainable as possible, utilizing advanced methods that minimize waste and maximize efficiency.
  • Client-Centric Approach: At Commonwealth Contractors, we believe in a collaborative approach, involving our clients at every step to ensure satisfaction. We strive to make the decking process smooth and enjoyable, ensuring that your vision is realized with the utmost professionalism and care.
class SampleComponent extends React.Component { 
  // using the experimental public class field syntax below. We can also attach  
  // the contextType to the current class 
  static contextType = ColorContext; 
  render() { 
    return <Button color={this.color} /> 

Planning Resources

Read more Aticles